Egyptian woman tells what happened
A year after the "Fourth and Renaissance" sit-in on August 14, 2013, a comprehensive report issued by the National Council for Human Rights revealed the falsity of the "Brotherhood" claims and their trade with the blood of Salat, the first to be questioned.
The report, which contained the facts in numbers, pictures and documents, convinced everyone except the Muslim Brotherhood, Qatar, Turkey and the Americans. "Quadruple" sees only the support of the terrorist group, even if it is contrary to the truth.
The Brotherhood claims that the police murdered them and deliberately ignored more than 300 martyrs of the police who were killed by the Brotherhood bullets. They even overlook more than 60 churches that were burned and attacked, and more than 180 police installations that were vandalized.
The question now is: Can a new year reveal new facts that reveal what the Brotherhood has already tried? .
Armed sit-in
Met with a number of experts and specialists to know their views on this subject, and was the beginning with Salah Suleiman, a human rights expert, who confirmed that the sit-in "fourth" was an armed sit-in to overthrow the state and was causing the obstruction of traffic and the state was not controlled by the inability of the Egyptian administration to enter And its negative impact on the surrounding population was considerable, as well as the existence of illegal practices, including the detention of a number of citizens in the sit-in.
Suleiman stressed that it was necessary for the state to impose its full powers on every part of its territory, and it was necessary to carry out the procedures of the space and as the state is committed to the law and international conventions to deal with these matters the government authorized the Ministry of the Interior after the authorization of the Public Prosecutor for the procedures of space To deal with it and this has already happened where the Interior provided more than 10 warnings, but negotiated with the leaders of the "Brotherhood" in the interest of life, but as a result of intransigence and rejection of all attempts and warnings, Maha international standards in accordance with the Code for dealing in arms by the men of the state law enforcement officials in accordance with the codes of conduct of the United Nations behavior.
The Human Rights report is biased
"The Egyptian state is a sovereign state and its sovereignty is exercised on its territory, especially since this organization is always biased and objective, and the Egyptian state has demanded that the report of the organization be reviewed, according to what I learned from the media," Suleiman said. However, the insistence of Human Rights Watch officials on the entry of their delegates and the release of the non-neutral report at this time confirms the bad faith and deliberately abuse the Egyptian state and therefore the Egyptian administration refused to enter the country. "
Mechanisms .. Fact-finding
On the other hand, the independent fact-finding committee in the events after June 30 reported that it had received a Human Rights Watch report on the dismantling of the fourth sit-in and the uprising, noting that the Human Rights report overlooked important facts such as the destruction of churches, the assault on Christians and their property, violence in universities, Police installations.
In its statement, the committee said that it has a more thorough and objective approach, mechanisms and content in the fact-finding committee, and that it is serious in carrying out its report, taking into consideration the shortcomings and gaps in the report due to lack of information.
The Commission added that the Human Rights Watch briefing on the events of a fourth sit-in would be received by the Commission with great care as it included the vision of the protesters and participants in some important events such as Qab'a, Nahdha, the Republican Guard and the Platform. They were parties that did not respond to calls. Committee in cooperation with it.
She pointed out that in all cases, the report helps to complete the picture before the Committee and will provide the information in order to arrive at the truth and that the Committee is the closest to events and the most thorough and deep and careful not to issue prejudices in events that are still under investigation and research.
The Committee renewed the call for all international and local human rights organizations, victims and families of victims to cooperate with the Commission and to provide them with all the information and evidence available to them. The Committee shall ensure the confidentiality of their data and prevent them from trading with any official and civil authority.
The Committee stressed its keenness to preserve the confidentiality of the information received, stressing that this is a principle in the work of fact-finding committees. It does not contradict transparency. The committee reveals its methodology and procedures without announcing the results that will be included in the report until it is completed.
Legal proceedings
For his part, Major General Osama al-Taweel, the former assistant interior minister, said: "The state should have dismantled this sit-in because of the seriousness of their presence and the Egyptian state has been under the focus of international attention in full and it was necessary to follow all legal procedures in disbanding the sit- It was required by law to dispel demonstrations, especially after the meeting of the National Defense Council and the approval of all concerned bodies on the need to break the sit-in, and there was information that the protesters in the fourth and Nahdha carrying firearms and the Ministry of the Interior repeated warning them to stop the sit-in and identify A safe exit for them, as happened during the events of the mosque conquest, but the protesters did not comply with the warning and they attacked the troops and was the first martyr is an officer from the Ministry of the Interior.
Major General Osama al-Taweel continued: "There is no doubt that the operation of the fugitive was carried out in all legal ways and was live on air and with the presence of all civil society organizations and carried out in accordance with the law."
Testimony of "Sister of the first martyr"
On the other hand, says Shaima Mahmoud Abdul Aziz sister of the martyr Capt. Mohammed Mahmoud Abdel Aziz, "that her brother Martyr Mohammed is the first martyr in the field of renaissance, where he was in the first armored to break the sit-in and began Altnb